2UrbanGirls
  • Home
  • Local
    • Compton
    • Education
    • Inglewood
    • Los Angeles
    • Orange County
  • News
    • Elections
  • Business
  • Crime
  • Opinion
    • Letter to the Editor
    • Word on the Streets
  • Things to Do
    • Arts & Culture
    • Entertainment
  • About
    • Advertise
    • Mediakit
  • Shop
    • Cart

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

What's Hot
March 26, 2023

Inglewood Transit Connector JPA to hold meeting March 29

March 26, 2023

Powerball jackpot grows to $122 million

March 26, 2023

`John Wick: Chapter 4′ opens with $73.5 Million

Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • Inglewood Transit Connector JPA to hold meeting March 29
  • Powerball jackpot grows to $122 million
  • `John Wick: Chapter 4′ opens with $73.5 Million
  • Authorities ID man found dead after police pursuit
  • Former NFL star sued over attack at West Hollywood club
  • Man shot while driving through South LA
  • SuperLotto Plus jackpot grows to $45 million
  • Authorities ID pedestrian killed by driver in Pomona
Facebook Twitter YouTube TikTok Instagram
2UrbanGirls
  • Home
  • Local
    1. Compton
    2. Education
    3. Inglewood
    4. Los Angeles
    5. Orange County
    6. View All

    Compton College Diverse Workforce Hiring Meets Benchmarks

    March 22, 2023

    Compton College to host job fair March 25

    March 21, 2023

    Authorities offer $20,000 reward for help solving murder of former NBA player’s father

    March 21, 2023

    Compton shooting leaves one dead

    March 17, 2023

    LAUSD, unions reach tentative labor deal with assistance of Mayor Karen Bass

    March 25, 2023

    Inglewood school board meeting erupts into chaos during vote on school closure

    March 24, 2023

    LAUSD schools reopen as three-day strike ends

    March 24, 2023

    Cerritos College looks forward to a permanent Child Development Center

    March 23, 2023

    Inglewood Transit Connector JPA to hold meeting March 29

    March 26, 2023

    El Camino College Board Trustee Ken Brown has died

    March 23, 2023

    Inglewood Councilwoman-elect has yet to resign from water board seats

    March 21, 2023

    Inglewood increasing trash rates, again

    March 20, 2023

    Metro train hits ANOTHER pedestrian

    February 20, 2023

    LA city council approves relocation assistance for tenants following rent increases

    February 7, 2023

    LA Mayor makes new appoints to police commission

    February 7, 2023

    LA council committee backs ending COVID testing for unvaccinated employees

    February 7, 2023

    Off-duty Orange County deputy dies in single-vehicle crash

    February 9, 2023

    2 dead after wrong-way driver causes multi-vehicle crash in Orange County

    February 6, 2023

    Pedestrian killed while crossing street in Orange County

    February 6, 2023

    Man faces life sentence for kidnapping, rape of girl in Orange County

    February 4, 2023

    Powerball jackpot grows to $122 million

    March 26, 2023

    SuperLotto Plus jackpot grows to $45 million

    March 26, 2023

    Biden nominee withdraws nomination to head FAA after Republican attacks

    March 25, 2023

    Winning Mega Millions lottery ticket sold in Long Beach

    March 25, 2023
  • News
    • Elections
  • Business
  • Crime
  • Opinion
    • Letter to the Editor
    • Word on the Streets
  • Things to Do
    • Arts & Culture
    • Entertainment
  • About
    • Advertise
    • Mediakit
  • Shop
    • Cart
2UrbanGirls
You are at:Home»Entertainment»Cardi B wins federal lawsuit over tattoo image
lev radin / Shutterstock

Cardi B wins federal lawsuit over tattoo image

0
By City News Service on October 22, 2022 Entertainment

By PAUL ANDERSON

SANTA ANA, Calif. – Jurors took about an hour Friday to find that singer Cardi B did not violate the privacy rights of a marketing employee of the Costa Mesa-based clothing company RVCA when she used an image of his tattoo on her debut album.

After the jurors rendered their verdict rejecting the claims of Kevin Michael Brophy Jr., Cardi B shook hands with him.

“At the end of the day I respect you as an artist,” Brophy told Cardi B. “We have a lot of mutual friends.”

The album cover, as pictured in December 2020.

Brophy told Cardi B that when he tried to contact her team to take care of the issue with the image of the tattoo on his back that was used for the album art no one responded.

“I didn’t know which way to turn,” he said.

After the hearing, Cardi B told reporters, “I was really nervous… I was a little emotional… I got a little scared,” as she awaited the verdict.

“But I am beyond grateful,” she added. “I really don’t do crying at all… but it means a lot to me, to my legal team, to everybody.”

She thanked her “really great lawyers… everyone was amazing.”

She said the legal conflict was an “interesting case. I think everybody really learned a lot.”

In his closing argument, Brophy’s attorney said Cardi B repeatedly “blew off” Brophy, who objected to the album art because the Photoshopping of a tattoo on a model made some people mistakenly think the tattoo artist was performing a sex act with her.

Brophy sued Belcalis Almanzar, known by her stage name Cardi B, alleging his privacy was invaded. He claimed in the federal suit misappropriation of a likeness, use of a likeness in violation of state law and false light.

An attorney for the rapper countered the plaintiff failed to produce any witnesses to back up Brophy’s claim. Cardi B’s attorneys mounted a First Amendment defense of “transformative use” because the portion of Brophy’s tattoo, which was lifted from an online image, was altered with Photoshop and placed on the back of another model.

“Mike Brophy’s privacy has been violated, invaded … in a way that is grossly offensive to him,” Brophy’s attorney Lawrence Conlan argued.

Brophy also sought an injunction from U.S. District Judge Cormac Carney to halt Cardi B’s future use of the cover of her debut album, “Gangster Bitch Music, Vol. 1.” The cover depicts the singer taking a swig of beer while a tattooed man performs oral sex on her in a car.

Brophy “is trying to be a role model” to young athletes in his job in marketing for the clothing brand. He spent a year and a half getting the tattoo from his friend, Fullerton artist Tim Hendricks.

Conlan argued that Brophy has suffered “humiliation” and “embarrassment” with “jabs” on social media about the album cover.

“He has not asked for it, doesn’t want it and he’s asked them to stop,” Conlan said.

The “back piece” tattoo is “part of his identity, and his identity is at the heart of this case,” Conlan argued.

The tattoo of a tiger and a serpent “is a masterpiece he carries on his skin,” Conlan argued. “And it is his alone to show it the way he wants to show it.”

Brophy is a “regular” guy with a wife and two “beautiful children,” who doesn’t seek notoriety, Conlan said. Part of his anxiety from the album cover stems from his fear of having to explain the image to his children one day.

“He’s terrified of the day he’s got to talk to his kids about what happened,” Conlan said. “He wants to be able to tell them he put a stop to it and got justice.”

When it came time for the photo shoot for the album, which was released in March 2016, no one liked the “Calvin and Hobbes” tattoo on the back of the Canadian model they used, Conlan said. So the graphic designer found the image of Brophy’s tattoo and used a portion of it to Photoshop onto the model, Conlan said.

Conlan argued that music industry professionals especially should understand the importance of getting consent before using an image. When Brophy sent a cease-and-desist letter, Cardi B’s representatives just “blew it off,” Conlan argued.

Conlan played clips of Cardi B during her deposition in the case as she dismissed Brophy’s claim.

“I didn’t give a (expletive) about this tattoo,” Cardi B said in the deposition, referring to the model’s original skin art. “So what does that got to do with me?”

Cardi B said she thought the model was “real cute” and that the primary focus of the art was her face in the picture.

“Do you have any proof this man is distressed,” she added during the deposition. “How is this affecting your life … It’s ridiculous. It’s wasting my time. It’s wasting my money.”

Conlan argued that the singer “wasn’t acknowledging his feelings.”

All her camp had to do was crop the image, as was done on the vinyl released in April 2020, to remove the model, Conlan argued.

Conlan said Cardi B has made $1.3 million in profits from the album and suggested that the jury could have taken all of it, or any amount of it, away and give it to his client. He also said the jury could have awarded his client $100,000 to $500,000 for five elements alleged, including humiliation and embarrassment.

He accused Cardi B of putting profits ahead of his client’s privacy.

Cardi B’s attorney, Peter Anderson, countered that it was Brophy who was chasing dollars instead of restoring his reputation.

Anderson noted that Brophy had five years of litigation to produce witnesses who could testify that the plaintiff has been teased or harassed about the album cover.

“He hasn’t proved any of these texts or social media postings taking jabs at Mr. Brophy,” Anderson said. “Why didn’t they call any of those people? … Cardi B was right. She said it in her own way, but where are these witnesses?”

Anderson also argued that no one would mistake Brophy for the model on the album, because the model is a Black man with a full head of hair and Brophy has a shaved head and is white.

“Anyone would know by looking at the artwork that’s not Mike Brophy,” Anderson said.

Furthermore, Cardi B, who has millions of followers on social media, posted pictures of her with the model from the album art photo shoot, Anderson said.

“The model himself also posted photos like this,” Anderson said.

The image of the tiger is a common one in the world of tattoos, Anderson argued.

“This is not a copyright claim,” which would require the appropriation of a person’s identity, Anderson argued. “His face is nowhere depicted in the artwork.”

“Their entire case is, `We asked them to stop,”‘ Anderson said. “This is not about asking anyone to stop. It was about trying to get as much money as you can.”

Related

Cardi B Cardi B lawsuit celebrity news tattoo image
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
City News Service

City News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside and San Diego counties. Its reporting and editing staff cover public safety, courts, local government and general assignment stories.

Related Posts

`John Wick: Chapter 4′ opens with $73.5 Million

Netflix sued over images used in reality TV series ad

Walmart presents Pharrell Williams’ Something in the Water Festival

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Most Read
Crime
March 10, 20230

Orange County movie theater evacuated after fight breaks out

ORANGE, Calif. – A movie theater was evacuated after a fight broke out which lead…

March 25, 2023

Winning Mega Millions lottery ticket sold in Long Beach

March 12, 2023

New York bank shutdown closes LA, OC offices

March 9, 2023

Women ordered to strand trial for the death of a woman seeking a BBL

Elections
March 24, 2023

Early in-person voting begins Saturday in LA special election

March 21, 2023

Grace Yoo announces candidacy for Los Angeles Council District 10

March 21, 2023

2022 election data shows Republicans gained in majority Latino districts

March 11, 2023

Gloria Gray maintains lead in Inglewood runoff election

Entertainment
March 26, 2023

`John Wick: Chapter 4′ opens with $73.5 Million

March 25, 2023

Netflix sued over images used in reality TV series ad

March 22, 2023

Walmart presents Pharrell Williams’ Something in the Water Festival

March 21, 2023

Kim Fields, Nathan Mitchell among celebrity presenters for 42nd College Television Awards

Business
March 22, 2023

Should I use credit cards to pay my insurance premiums?

March 21, 2023

Ways your business can give back to charity

March 21, 2023

Black Tech Week returns to Cincinatti this summer

March 20, 2023

Sofi’s campaign to stop the student-loan payment pause

Transportation
March 25, 2023

Biden nominee withdraws nomination to head FAA after Republican attacks

March 25, 2023

CA Transportation Commission awards millions to LA County for infrastructure projects

March 24, 2023

County Supervisor issues statement on extending law enforcement contracts for Metro transit services

March 24, 2023

Inglewood requests cancellation of Centinela Grade Separation project, wants funds shifted to transit connector

Sports
March 26, 2023

Former NFL star sued over attack at West Hollywood club

March 20, 2023

Magic Johnson part of group making bid for Washington Commanders

March 20, 2023

Inglewood’s SoFi Stadium in danger of losing 2026 World Cup hosting rights

March 15, 2023

Kobe Bryant’s hand, footprints to be unveiled outside TCL Chinese Theatre

Real Estate
March 24, 2023

California may scale down new loan program designed to assist first-time homebuyers

February 28, 2023

In a World of Shrinking Apartments, L.A. Rentals Got Bigger – Here’s Why 

February 27, 2023

Homes owned by Black families appreciated the fastest during the pandemic

February 17, 2023

Top 50 Most Expensive L.A. County Neighborhoods in 2022

Legal
March 16, 2023

Former employee identified in lawsuit against Encino doctor

February 7, 2023

Black tenant seeks to intervene in ongoing discrimination case

February 2, 2023

Juice bar chain pays $175,000 to settle federal discrimination claims

February 1, 2023

Grand Jury indicts disbarred attorney Tom Girardi for embezzling $15M from clients

Newsletter

Recent Posts
  • Inglewood Transit Connector JPA to hold meeting March 29
  • Powerball jackpot grows to $122 million
  • `John Wick: Chapter 4′ opens with $73.5 Million
  • Authorities ID man found dead after police pursuit
  • Former NFL star sued over attack at West Hollywood club
Recent Comments
  • So Disappointing on LA Councilman’s public corruption trial turns to his son, Sebastian Ridley-Thomas’ health issues
  • Suspicious or prophetic beginnings ? on Opinion: Inglewood City Clerk is dragging her feet swearing in Councilwoman Gloria Gray
  • More concerns than MRT on More from the FBI agent’s testimony in L.A. City Councilman Mark Ridley-Thomas’ criminal trial
Copyright © 2011-2023 2UrbanGirls.
  • Cookie Policy
  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

 

Loading Comments...